Home / Automotive / Renault ZOE vs. Nissan LEAF

Renault ZOE vs. Nissan LEAF

Admittedly, we didn’t make it straightforward for our two take a look at candidates. Whereby “we” is definitely incorrect. As a result of if it have been as much as us, our two take a look at candidates may show themselves at milder temperatures, however so the 2 Stromer needed to present what they’ll do in freezing chilly.


It’s now recognized to many who electrical autos, or their typically put in lithium-ion batteries, should not essentially spurred on by sub-zero temperatures. However we may hardly consider that the LEAF or ZOE had a variety of round 100 kilometers as a substitute of round 200 instantly after full charging and probably the most mild driving type.

Within the second quarter of 2015 -reported – it obtained a brand new engine specifically developed by Renault and, in the most effective case, ought to now have the ability to cowl 240 kilometers with out recharging. To start with: Neither the ZOE nor the LEAF reached the manufacturing facility specification – which had already been introduced by the data show.
For those who suppose we now have not made an effort, we advocate the next take a look at situation: Departure with the ZOE at 11 a.m. (as a result of there may be little site visitors), absolutely charged (after all), with out heating (regretted afterwards) from the Kemmelbach service station on the West Autobahn close to Ybbs) at Three levels exterior temperature. It went instantly on the A1 in the direction of Vienna, the cruise management was set to 80 km / h. The remaining vary reveals 127 kilometers.
The primary 40-ton truck caught to my neck after barely ten minutes. The next 5 minutes are characterised by mild flare assaults earlier than he overtakes me on the three-lane freeway with a gentle horn. However by no means thoughts, I form of anticipated that earlier than the beginning.
I used to be much less involved concerning the fogging of all automobile home windows. Nevertheless, as a result of the windscreen remained free to such an extent that driving security was not restricted, the heating additionally failed to seem. After half an hour of driving, my ft have been ice chilly. However what you do not do for a great vary.
After a 90 km drive over the “west entrance” in Vienna Auhof at seven levels “heat”, the clock confirmed 12:10, the remaining vary show 43 kilometers. By the way, it ought to be famous that this was the primary time that I needed to brake. In between, the cruise-controlled drive was not often interrupted.
After 118 kilometers I lastly reached Vienna Donaustadt at 12:45 p.m. The remaining vary show stood at 27 kilometers. The ZOE and I had completed it. I used to be even in a position to make up nearly 20 km. Perhaps I may have turned on the heater.
With an outdoor temperature of lower than 10 levels and any acceleration orgies spared, and no heating activated, round 150 kilometers could be completed with the ZOE and its 22 kWh battery. Issues did not look significantly better right here with the Nissan LEAF with a 24 kWh battery …
Though the 109 HP LEAF, in distinction to the 70 HP weak ZOE, doesn’t have halogen however moderately energy-saving LED dipped headlights and is just 57 kilograms heavier, it nonetheless has 18 kilometers of remaining vary on arrival in Vienna.
If you would like extra driving pleasure and fewer concern concerning the vary, select the Nissan. He takes a clean two seconds off the ZOE when sprinting to 100 km / h (11.5 to 13.5 s). The identical applies to the gear choices. For instance, no leather-based seats are provided for the ZOE. The French additionally lack extras akin to seat heating for the rear seat. After all, all of that is mirrored within the value …
Whereas the ZOE is accessible from € 21,390, the LEAF prices a minimum of € 22,661 – each costs are unique of month-to-month battery lease. With the ZOE and the LEAF, this prices a minimum of 79 euros – with a mileage of 12,500 km and a working time of greater than 36 months. The battery rents are variably adjustable yearly.
What we’re at the moment feeling unhealthy about is the final circumstances with which electrical automobile drivers must combat: patrons pay between 79 and 142 euros battery lease monthly, relying on the mileage. If that is not sufficient, varied charging playing cards must be bought, as a result of if you wish to refuel exterior and discover a station – fortuitously there at the moment are greater than sufficient of them – you simply want the corresponding card from the respective supplier. And since additionally they need to have paid off their investments in charging stations in some unspecified time in the future, most non-public “petrol stations” could be present in costly parking garages. And at Vienna-Schwechat Airport there isn’t a freely accessible fast charging station in any respect.
Conclusion: Electrical automobiles make sense, no query in any respect. 100 kilometers could be lined below nearly all environmental and driver influences. However to be sincere, neither the Renault ZOE nor the Nissan LEAF pays off below the adversarial controls that personal homeowners are at the moment combating. Hopefully, the subject will turn out to be extra attention-grabbing right here with the 30 kWh LEAF facelift, which is at the moment being launched and is accessible from 27,660 euros.Knowledge take a look at automobile | 2015 Renault ZOE Intens R240 | Base value: 23,450 euros with battery rental | Motor: three-phase synchronous motor | Energy: 43 kW / 59 PS (quick time period 65 kW / 88 PS from 3,000–11,300 1 / min) | Torque: 220 Nm from 250 to 2,500 rpm | Gearbox: discount gearbox, operation as for computerized | Drive: entrance | Acceleration: 13.5 s | High velocity: 135 km / h | Battery: Lithium-ion laminated (400 V) | Capability: 22 kWh | Customary consumption: 13.Three kWh / 100 km (based on NEDC) | CO2 emissions: zero g / km | Check consumption: ~ 16-18 kWh / 100 km | Vary: 240 km (based on NEDC) | General size / width / peak: 4,085 / 1,730 / 1,562 mm | Wheelbase: 2,588 mm | Turning circle: 10.65 m | Boot house: 338–1,225 l | Empty weight: 1.468 kg | permissible whole weight: 1,965 kg

Knowledge take a look at automobile | 2015 Nissan LEAF Tekna 24 kWh | Base value: 28,061 euros with battery rental | Motor: three-phase synchronous motor | Energy: 80 kW / 109 hp from 3,800–10,000 rpm | Torque: 254 Nm from zero to three,008 rpm | Gearbox: discount gearbox, operation as for computerized | Axle ratio: 8.19: 1 | Drive: entrance | Acceleration: 11.5 s | High velocity: 144 km / h | Battery: Lithium-ion laminated (360 V) | Capability: 24 kWh (48 modules) Customary consumption: 15 kWh / 100 km (based on UN ECE 101) CO2 emissions: zero g / km | Check consumption: ~ 18–20 kWh / 100 km | Vary: 199 km (based on NEDC) | Whole size / width / peak: 4,445 / 1,770 / 1,550 mm | Wheelbase: 2,700 mm | Turning circle: 10.Four m | Boot house: 355–720 l | Empty weight: 1,525 kg | permissible whole weight: 1,945 kg

About kadir

45 queries 0,471